Why Dieting Doesn’t Always Work (and How to Make Healthy Changes That Last)
If you’ve ever started a diet full of motivation—only to find yourself back at square one a few months later—you are so not alone. In fact, at any given moment, about one in three Americans is on some kind of diet, usually to lose weight. But here’s the kicker: even when diets “work,” the weight often creeps back within months.
So… why does this happen?
There are a few big reasons:
The diet is too strict. It cuts out too many foods you like, and you eventually get tired of feeling deprived.
Life gets in the way. Work, family, stress—it’s easy to slip back into old habits.
Less movement sneaks in. Some people move less when eating fewer calories, which can stall progress.
Your body adapts. Even if you do everything “right,” your metabolism can slow down, making it harder to keep losing.
And here’s the tough truth: even in research studies where people have every meal planned, calories counted, exercise scheduled, and coaches cheering them on most of the weight and health benefits fade once the program ends.
What the research says
A huge study published in The BMJ looked at 121 trials with nearly 22,000 people on 14 popular diets—things like Atkins, Weight Watchers, DASH, and the Mediterranean diet.
what they found:
At 6 months: People on low-carb and low-fat diets lost about 10 pounds and saw modest improvements in blood pressure and cholesterol.
At 12 months: Most of the weight came back, and those health improvements disappeared.
One bright spot: The Mediterranean diet kept LDL (“bad”) cholesterol lower even after a year.
Bottom line: No single diet was dramatically better than the rest over time.
What actually matters
If this sounds discouraging, don’t give up yet there’s good news. The real secret isn’t finding the perfect diet…it’s finding a way of eating you actually enjoy and can stick with long term.
Think about it: if you love the food you’re eating, you’re way more likely to keep going. Add in regular movement, enough sleep, and small changes you can live with, and you’ve got a much better shot at lasting results.
Why I’m a fan of the Mediterranean approach
It’s balanced, flexible, and full of flavor. We’re talking:
Lots of fruits, vegetables, and whole grains
Healthy fats from olive oil, nuts, and fish
Moderate amounts of dairy, poultry, and wine
Very little processed food or added sugar
It’s not about rigid rules it’s about enjoying real, nourishing food.
Final thoughts
Losing weight is tough, and short-term diets rarely deliver lasting change. But you don’t have to aim for perfection you just have to find healthy habits you like enough to keep doing.
Create a strategy for your life that feels achievable by consulting with your physician, a nutritionist, or a health coach. Make an effort to move your body frequently, eat in a way that fuels you, and obtain adequate sleep.
What's Your Reaction?
